Analysis of Ophthalmic Plastic Procedures in a Tertiary Centre
Orbito-oculoplastics diseases and deformities tend to impact negatively on the psycho-social, economic as well as the educational achievement of affected persons. Ophthalmic plastic procedures are performed to improve the appearance and function of the eyelids and face of the affected person.
To determine the prevalence and indications of oculoplastic procedures in oculopastic subspecialty in order to provide data base for management of ophthalmic plastic conditions in our centre.
The clinic and theatre records of all patients that had oculoplastic procedures done from January 2015 – July 2017 were retrieved to obtain demographic characteristics, duration of symptoms, presenting visual acuity and oculoplastic procedures and histo-pathological diagnosis from the records.
One hundred and eighty (180) patients had oculo-plastic surgery. This constituted (12.1%) of all surgeries done in this centre. There were 95(52.8%) males and 85 (48.2%) females with a male to female ratio of 1.1:1. Conjunctival disorders 106(58.9%) were the most frequent with two third occurring at 40 years and above. This was followed by disorders arising from trauma with greater than 2/3 occurring at younger age group. Most of the ophthalmic cosmetic procedures were performed in the elderly females while the destructive procedures resulting from trauma were performed in the young males.
The incidence of ophthalmic plastic procedure was low. There is need fortraining of more staff with adequate and relevant skill in more advance cosmetic oculoplastic surgery and provision of up to date equipments required for various procedures in order to improve the practice of this subspecialty in this centre.
The eyes otherwise referred to as the “window to the soul” reveal so much about a person’s personality, feelings, mood, overall general appearance and self image1.Any deformity or disorder around the eye and orbit can negatively impact on the psychosocial, economic as well as educational achievement of affected persons2. Apart from the concerns about the function of the eyes, individuals also have great concerns about their cosmetic appearance3. The Ophthalmic plastic surgeons assist patients to restore youthfulness around the eyes and orbit in terms of function and appearance4. Following the establishment of an Ophthalmic plastic unit in our centre after the completion of the required training by a specialist eye doctor, this study has been carried out to determine how much of these procedures have been done after 3 years as well as the indications. The findings from this study will form a database for ophthalmic plastic conditions in our centre.
Materials and Methods
One hundred and eighty (180) patients with ophthalmic plastic conditions of all age groups, both male and female in our centre were derived from either self referral, General Ophthalmology Clinics within the centre or other centres within and outside the state. The clinic and theatre records of all patients who had Oculoplastic procedures between January 2015 and July 2017 were retrieved. All patients were examined by the oculoplastic surgeon following referral from ophthalmologists from other subspecialty (Retina, Glaucoma and general ophthalmology clinics) after which clinical diagnoses were made. Demographic characteristics, duration of symptoms, presenting visual acuity, oculoplastic procedures and histo-pathological diagnosis were obtained from the records. Visual acuity were categorized with ≥ 6/18 as normal, <6/18 to >3/60 as visual impairment and <3/60 as blindness. Infants were classified as either blind or believed not to be blind. Ethical approval was obtained from the institution’s ethical review committee though data collection did not directly involve patient’s participation. Data obtained were recorded and analysed using Statiscal Package for Social Sciences (SPSS) version 20. Means (Standard deviations) were used to describe the distributions of continuous variables. Categorical variables were described in Percentages. Comparisons of categorical data were performed with the use of Pearson’s chi-square test. P < 0.05 was considered statistically significant.
One hundred and eighty (180) patients had oculo-plastic surgery during this period. This constituted (12.1%) of all surgeries(1,493) done in this centre. There were 95(52.8%) males and 85 (48.2%) females with a male to female ratio of 1.1:1. The ages ranged from 7 months to 81 years with mean age of 41.45±20.67 years.
|AGE (YRS)||MALE (%)||FEMALE (%)|
|Oculoplastic diseases||<40years (%)||≥40years (%)||Total (%)|
FFS-Fornix Foramation Suture, MMG-Mucous Membrane Graft Most of the procedures (Pterygium, FFS+MMG, Electrolysis and Ptosis) were performed in the females while the destructive procedures, corneal repair and lid surgery resulting from trauma were performed in males The procedure done was unilateral in 176(97.8%) eyes with 97(53.9%) of the cases done for the right eye.
The ophthalmic plastic procedures done for the various orbito-ocular diseases in this study constituted 12.1% of all ophthalmic surgeries done in this centre. This is much lower than 60.6% of all minor ophthalmic plastic procedures recorded in Northern part of the country1. However their study covered seven years period and involved all minor procedures like incision and curettage which were excluded in this study1. Many other studies reported the incidence of various individual procedures2,5–7. The low incidence could be because of the young age of the oculoplastic subspecialty with limited available facilities. There was a significant male preponderance which is contrary to a study done in another centre of the same geographical location of the country2. More males tend to access eye facility than their female counterparts because of reasons like financial prowess of men. Women on the other hand have limited freedom due to their engrossment in domestic8 even though it is a known fact that females are more sensitive to the imposed cosmetic disfigurement arising from oculoplastic disorders2. Majority of the patients were 40years and above, this might be due to a large contribution of conditions like degenerative eye diseases affecting the elderly6. Conjunctival disorders were the most frequent with Pterygium as the leading etiological cause. This was contrary to a report from another study at the same geographical location of the country where eyelid diseases was the commonest2. Two third of the cases were 40 years and above. Pterygium is a degenerative disease of the bulbar conjunctival tissue which progressively encroaches on the cornea in a triangular fashion. Increasing age have been reported to be one of the independent risk factors in pterygium presentation9. Pterygium apart from constituting threat to vision by encroachment into the visual axis can also constitute a cosmetic blemish. Other conjunctival disorders included Ocular Surface Squamous Neoplasia (OSSN)which is the third most common ocular tumor in adults10.Few cases of symblepharon, pyogenic granuloma were documented. Moreover, trauma ranked second common estaetiologcal causes of orbito-ocular diseases occurring in young individual of less than 40 years in this study as more young males were involved in activities that can result in severe facial injury11–13. This was similar to a study in Lagos where trauma was the leading aetiological factors causing severe facial injury2. Few cases of Retinoblastoma were seen in this study. Retinoblastoma is the most common malignant intraocular tumour in children14. This is similar to some other studies in Nigeria14.However no single case of retinoblastoma was reported by Balogun et al., in her study of orbito-ocular diseases in Lagos2. Most of the ophthalmic cosmetic procedures (Pterygium, FFS+MMG, Electrolysis and Ptosis) were performed in the females while the destructive procedures resulting from trauma were performed in the males similar to some authors6,15. The methods done for pterygium were pterygium excision with intra operative application of 5 Fluoro Uracil and excision with autograft in order to prevent recurrence. The destructive procedures performed were evisceration with or without orbital implant, enucleation with orbital implant and insertion of conformer and later fixing ocular prosthesis and deepening of orbital socket from previously contracted socket. Norris et al., reported that Madagascan ophthalmic practitioners centre their attention on enucleation, evisceration, and exenteration for presumed traumatic and neoplastic causes16 and most common causes for eye removal in African countries are both trauma and orbito-ocular tumours15.This is not different from our findings in this centre. In addition, some patients with infections/inflammatory causes resulting in painful blindness had evisceration performed on them and they are to have secondary orbital implant after the infection has been curtailed.
All patients with clinical diagnosis of OSSN had excisional biopsy with Alcohol Kerato Epitheliectomy (AKET) using standard oculopastic procedure of no touch technique and wide excision margin of 3-4 mm. Only few patients had bilateral procedure done on the same day.
The incidence of ophthalmic procedure was low;most of the ophthalmic cosmetic procedures were performed in the elderly females while the destructive procedures resulting from trauma were performed in the young males. A lot more procedures can still be done in this oculoplastic subspecialty. In order to improve the oculoplastic practice, there is need for training of more staff with adequate and relevant skill in more advance cosmetic oculoplastic surgery and provision of up to date equipments required for various procedures.
- History of ocular trauma in tehran population: Tehran eye study. Iranian Journal of Ophthalmology. 2011;23(3):43-9.
- [Google Scholar]
- Pattern of presentation and factors leading to ocular trauma. Pak J Ophthalmol. 2011;27(2):96-102.
- [Google Scholar]
- Epidemiological survey of traumatic eye injury in a Southwestern Nigeria tertiary hospital. Pakistan Journal of Ophthalmology. 2014;30(3):138.
- [Google Scholar]